Copart Inc. (CPRT) Drops 3.04% After Earnings, Beats EPS and Revenue Below Consensus

2025-11-21 · Stocks · QuoteReporter

Post Earning Analysis

Copart Inc. (CPRT) Drops 3.04% After Earnings, Beats EPS and Revenue Below Consensus

Copart, Inc., founded in 1982 and headquartered in Dallas, Texas, specializes in online auctions and vehicle remarketing services. Utilizing its advanced Virtual Bidding Third Generation (VB3) technology, Copart offers comprehensive services for processing and selling vehicles over the internet. The company primarily serves licensed dismantlers, rebuilders, and used vehicle dealers, along with exporters and, in some locations, the general public. Copart operates both in the United States and internationally, providing a suite of services including salvage estimation, transportation, and DMV processing.

Copart, Inc. (CPRT) recently disclosed its financial results, revealing a mixed performance in the market. On November 20, 2025, the company reported surpassing Q1 earnings estimates, as highlighted by Zacks, but failed to meet revenue expectations due to weakened demand for used cars, according to Reuters. This revenue shortfall was also noted in a separate report by StockStory, emphasizing the company’s challenges in the third quarter of the calendar year 2025.

Despite these challenges, Copart demonstrated strong profit growth in the first quarter of fiscal 2026, as detailed in their earnings call highlights provided by GuruFocus.com. This suggests resilience in profitability amidst prevailing market pressures, which include fluctuating insurance and auction trends that are impacting market share, as discussed in a deep dive analysis by StockStory.

Additionally, an analyst report from Morningstar Research provided further insights into Copart’s current market position, although specific details from this report were not disclosed. These developments could influence investor sentiment and potentially impact Copart’s stock performance as the market digests both the earnings success and the revenue misses.

The provided price metrics indicate a bearish trend for the asset in question. The current price of $39.41, just above its 52-week and year-to-date lows of $39.38, suggests significant downward pressure. This is accentuated by today’s decline of 3.04%, pushing the price closer to these critical support levels.

The asset is trading well below its moving averages: 5.68% below the 20-day MA, 9.86% below the 50-day MA, and a substantial 22.18% below the 200-day MA. This separation from the moving averages further confirms a strong bearish trend.

The asset’s performance relative to its 52-week high of $64.38 and year-to-date high of $63.85 (declines of approximately 38.79% and 38.28%, respectively) highlights a significant retracement over the past year.

Technical indicators reinforce this negative outlook. An RSI of 28.22 suggests the asset is in oversold territory, which could indicate a potential for rebound or stabilization, yet this is contradicted by the MACD of -0.99, emphasizing ongoing downward momentum. The proximity of the current price to its recent lows, coupled with negative indicators, suggests that caution is warranted, as further declines could be imminent unless a reversal pattern emerges.

Copart, Inc. (NASDAQ: CPRT) reported its financial results for the first quarter of fiscal year 2026, ending October 31, 2025. The company achieved a total revenue of $1.16 billion, marking a modest increase of 0.7% from the same quarter the previous year. Notably, net income attributable to Copart, Inc. saw a significant rise of 11.5%, reaching $403.7 million. This growth was reflected in the earnings per share (EPS), with fully diluted EPS increasing by 11.7% to $0.41 and basic EPS up by 11.0% to $0.42.

Service revenues totaled $991.8 million, with a slight decline in the U.S. market but a 7.9% increase internationally. Vehicle sales also varied, with U.S. sales up by 10.8% while international sales declined by 9.4%. Total operating expenses decreased by 2.2% to $724.3 million, contributing to the overall profitability.

Additionally, net cash provided by operating activities improved to $535.3 million. The company’s total assets grew to $10.58 billion, and total stockholders’ equity increased to $9.60 billion. Despite these positive financial metrics, Copart did not declare a quarterly dividend nor indicate any share repurchase programs for this period.

Earnings Trend Table

Analyzing the EPS trends from the data provided, a pattern of fluctuating performance relative to estimates emerges. Initially, in the quarter ending November 2023, the company exceeded expectations with a reported EPS of 0.34 against an estimate of 0.33, resulting in a surprise of 4.62%. However, the subsequent quarters show variability in the company’s ability to meet or surpass expectations.

In early 2024, there was a noticeable dip in performance with the reported EPS falling below estimates in February and September, showing surprises of -4.78% and -9.14% respectively. This trend reversed towards the end of 2024 and into 2025, where the company consistently met or exceeded EPS estimates. Notably, the quarters ending in February and November 2025 showed significant positive surprises of 7.82% and 5.21%, respectively.

This trajectory suggests that after a challenging start in early 2024, the company has made strides in either managing expectations more effectively or improving its operational efficiency, leading to better-than-expected financial results in later quarters. This improvement could be indicative of strategic adjustments or market conditions favoring the company’s offerings.

In the recent series of analyst ratings changes, the following notable adjustments were made:

1. Barclays – November 12, 2025: Barclays initiated coverage on Outer with an “Underweight” rating and a target price of $32. This initiation suggests a cautious perspective on the stock, implying that Barclays analysts believe the stock may underperform relative to its sector peers, potentially due to perceived weaknesses in its fundamentals or market position.

2. HSBC Securities – September 4, 2025: HSBC Securities upgraded their rating on Outer from “Hold” to “Buy” with a new target price of $62. This upgrade indicates a significant positive shift in HSBC’s valuation of Outer, suggesting improved operational performance or market conditions that could drive the stock’s future outperformance.

3. Stephens – July 8, 2025: Stephens initiated coverage on Outer with an “Equal-Weight” rating and a target price of $50. An “Equal-Weight” rating implies that Stephens views the company’s stock as adequately valued at its current price, expecting it to perform in line with the broader market or its industry.

4. Argus – March 14, 2025: Argus downgraded Outer from “Buy” to “Hold.” This change indicates a shift from a bullish to a neutral stance, with Argus possibly recognizing some emerging challenges or a lack of new growth catalysts that might limit the stock’s upside potential. No specific target price was provided with this downgrade.

These rating changes reflect a mixed sentiment among analysts concerning Outer’s stock, highlighting varying expectations on its financial health and market performance.

The current price of the stock is $39.41. This price is situated within a range of target prices given by various analysts. Barclays has the lowest target at $32, rating the stock as “Underweight,” suggesting a potential downside. On the other hand, HSBC Securities provides the highest target price at $62 and has upgraded the stock from “Hold” to “Buy,” indicating a significant potential upside. Stephens has a more moderate view with a target price of $50 and an “Equal-Weight” rating. Additionally, Argus has downgraded the stock from “Buy” to “Hold,” although no specific target price was provided with this change.

The variation in these target prices and ratings indicates a mixed outlook among analysts, reflecting differing perspectives on the stock’s future performance. This disparity suggests that while there are positive growth expectations from some analysts, others remain cautious, highlighting potential risks or challenges.

Disclaimer: The information provided here is for educational and informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as financial advice, investment recommendations, or trading guidance. Markets involve risk, and past performance is not indicative of future results. You should always conduct your own research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions. By acting, you accept full responsibility for your choices.